The factors of competition in municipal elections by example of the Volga federal district cities

Authors

  • U.I. Chadova Perm Federal Research Centre UB RAS

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.7242/2658-705X/2019.4.8

Keywords:

municipalities, elections, competition

Abstract

The purpose of the article is to identify the factors that determine the presence or absence of competition in municipal elections. The paper summarizes the theoretical material on the phenomenon of competition at the federal, regional and municipal levels. The formulated theoretical framework allowed to identify such factors as quality of life, ethnic composition of population, the proportion of age retirement population, the share of registered incumbent candidates in the elections. The main content of the research is a qualitative comparative analysis (QCA). The results of elections to the representative bodies of the largest urban districts and municipal districts of the Volga Federal district during the last electoral cycle were analyzed. The analysis determined that the presence of political machines in the territories with a predominance of ethnic population contributes to low competition. The paper also confirmed the claims that the high turnout, the predominance of candidates-incumbents in the elections causes a low level of competition in the elections. The assumption of the role of quality of life in increasing competition is controversial, because it has not received a certain result during the work. At the same time, the identified factors are ambiguous, as due to the limited empirical data, significant variables were probably not taken into account.

Author Biography

  • U.I. Chadova, Perm Federal Research Centre UB RAS
    лаборант отдела по исследованию политических институтов и процессов, Пермский федеральный исследовательский центр УрО РАН (ПФИЦ УрО РАН)

References

  1. Besplatnaa internet-biblioteka. Kacestvennyj sravnitel’nyj analiz. Susnost’ metoda Kacestvennyj sravnitel’nyj analiz (Qualitative Comparative Analysis) [Elektronnyj resurs] - URL: http://pdf.knigi-x.ru/21fizika/304548-1-102-kachestvenniy-sravnitelniy-analiz-suschnost-metoda- kachestvenniy-sravnitelniy-analiz-qualitative-compar.php (data obrasenia: 16.02.2019).
  2. Voroncov V.S. Rol’ etniceskogo faktora v vybornoj kampanii deputatov Gosudarstvennoj Dumy Federal’nogo Sobrania Rossijskoj Federacii sestogo sozyva // Antinomii: Naucnyj ezegodnik Instituta filosofii i prava UrO RAN. - 2012. - No 12. - S. 389-393.
  3. Gel’man V.A. <>: formirovanie konceptov v izucenii rossijskoj politiki // Polis. Politiceskie issledovania. - 2001. - No 6. - S. 6 - 18.
  4. Gel’man V.A. Ot <> - k <>? (Transformacia rossijskoj partijnoj sistemy) // Obsestvennye nauki i sovremennost’. - 2006. - No 1. - S. 46-58.
  5. Gel’man V., Ryzenkov S., Belokurova E., Borisova N. Reforma mestnoj vlasti v gorodah Rossii, 1991-2006. - SPb.: Norma, 2008. - 368 s.
  6. Golosov G.V. Cestnost’ vyborov i avka izbiratelej v usloviah avtoritarizma // Politiceskaa nauka. - 2019. - No 1. - S. 67-89.
  7. Lubarev A.E. Aktivnost’ izbiratelej na federal’nyh, regional’nyh i municipal’nyh vyborah v Rossijskoj Federacii // Sociodinamika. - 2013. - No 8. - S. 138-209.
  8. Ministerstvo finansov RF. Rascet raspredelenia dotacij na vyravnivanie budzetnoj obespecennosti mezdu sub"ektami Rossijskoj Federacii na 2018 god i planovyj period 2019 i 2020 godov [Elektronnyj resurs] - URL: https://www.minfin.ru/ru/ (data obrasenia: 05.03.1019).
  9. Polit.ru. Golosov G.V. Mir partijnyh sistem i partijnye sistemy mira [Elektronnyj resurs] - URL: https://polit.ru/article/2011/04/06/partyism/ (data obrasenia: 25.03.2019).
  10. Psevorskij A. Demokratia rynok. Politiceskie ekonomiceskie reformy Vostocnoj Evrope, Latinskoj Amerike: per. angl. / pod red. prof. Bazanova V.A. - M.: <> (ROSSPEN), 2000. - 320 s.
  11. RIAREJTING. Rossia Segodna [Elektronnyj resurs] - URL: http://riarating.ru/infografika/20180523/630091878.html (data obrasenia 05.03.2019).
  12. Rossijskaa gazeta. Kacestvo zizni v gorodah Rossii [Elektronnyj resurs] - URL: https://rgru/pril/article/162/11/08/73._Kachestvo_zhizni_v_gorodah_Rossii.pdf (data obrasenia: 07.01.2019)
  13. Central’naa Izbiratel’naa komissia RF. Svedenia o provodasihsa vyborah i referendumah [Elektronnyj resurs] - URL: http://www.vybory.izbirkom.ru (data obrasenia 23.12.2018).
  14. Spagin S.A. Regional’nye partijnye sistemy v sovremennoj Rossii: k metodologii issledovania // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Filosofia. Sociologia. Politologia. - 2012. - T. 19. - No 3. - S. 134-142.
  15. Domofond.ru. Polnyj rejting gorodov Rossii po kacestvu zizni v 2018 godu [Elektronnyj resurs] - URL: https://www.domofond.ru/statya/polnyy_reyting_gorodov_rossii_po_kachestvu_zhizni_v_2018_ godu/7679 (data obrasenia 12.01.2019).
  16. Downs A. Ap Economic Theory of Democracy // Midwest Journal of Political Science. - 1957.
  17. Giuliani M., Massari S. The economic vote at the party level: Electoral behaviour during the Great Recession // Party Politics. - 2017. - Vol. 49. - No 4. - P. 461-473.
  18. Hale H. Explaining machine politics in Russia’s regions: Economy, ethnicity, and legacy // Post-Soviet Affairs. - 2003. - No 3. - P. 228-263.
  19. Hale H. Why not parties in Russia? Democracy, federalism and the state. - Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 2006. - 275 p.
  20. Laakso M., Taagepera R. The <> Number of Parties: A Measure with Application to West Europe // Comparative Political Studies. - 1979.
  21. Mair P. Party System Change: Approaches and Interpretations. - Oxford: Clarendon press, 1998. - 264 p.
  22. Panov P., Ross C. Patterns of Electoral Contestation in Russian Regional Assemblies: Between Competitive and Hegemonic Authoritarianism // Demokratizatsiya. - 2013. - Vol. 21. - No 3. - P. 369-399.
  23. Stokes S. Perverse Accountability: A Formal Model of Machine Politics // American Political Science Review. - 2005. - Vol. 99. - No 3. - P. 315-325.

Published

2019-12-23

Issue

Section

Research: theory and experiment

How to Cite

Chadova, U. . (2019). The factors of competition in municipal elections by example of the Volga federal district cities. Perm Federal Research Centre Journal, 4, 70-78. https://doi.org/10.7242/2658-705X/2019.4.8